Automated Vehicle Crashes

Earlier this week, the Associated Press reported on several past crashes involving automated vehicles. (Per SAE Standard J3016, I use the term "automated vehicle" instead of "autonomous vehicle" or "self-driving car" or "driverless car.") A few thoughts:
1) As I wrote in 2012, we would need more information -- about the crashes themselves, the conditions under which each company's automated vehicles are tested, and the situations in which each company's test drivers intervene -- to provide statistical context for these incidents.
2) In some ways, the AP's inquiry gave us a preview of how public and private actors might respond to future automated vehicle crashes that actually result in injury or death. It may be instructive to view the reactions of Google, Delphi, and the California DMV in this light.
3) Over the last few years, I have advised both developers and regulators of automated systems to put in place specific plans for responding, both publicly and privately, to the first high-profile incidents involving these systems. My sense, however, is that many organizations still have not created these "break-the-glass" or "break-glass" plans.
4) Earlier this semester, my impressive Law of the Newly Possible students did develop two thoughtful break-glass plans: one for the developers of automated driving systems and another for the regulators of these systems. Interestingly, although the private-sector group and the public-sector group each recognized the need to communicate with each other in the event of a crash, each also hesitated in reaching out to the other in the course of planning. In the real world, a broad range of stakeholders should be coordinating these plans sooner rather than later.
5) My book chapter on Regulation and the Risk of Inaction, also released this week, identifies eight public-sector strategies for managing risks related to automated driving. It can be freely downloaded here. A key point is that we must expect more of conventional drivers as well as automated vehicles. To paraphrase myself: I'm concerned about computer drivers, but I'm terrified about human drivers.
6) As always, please visit for additional materials.

Add new comment